Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
35 Years
experience
Trusted ERISA Disability & Life Insurance Claims Lawyers
Founded in 1991, McDonald & McDonald has dedicated its practice to advocating for individuals denied employer-provided disability and life insurance benefits under ERISA. Our firm specializes in navigating complex insurance claims, including long-term and short-term disability, Social Security disability, and life insurance denials. With over three decades of combined legal experience, our attorneys meticulously gather medical evidence, secure expert testimonies, and construct compelling cases to prove clients' inability to perform job duties.

We operate on a contingency fee basis, ensuring clients pay no attorney fees unless we secure their benefits. Our personalized approach, supported by dedicated paralegals, emphasizes transparency, client education, and relentless advocacy. Recognized for our success in overturning denials, we serve clients across multiple states, prioritizing their needs over corporate interests. Our philosophy centers on collaborative strategy development, treating each case as unique while maintaining a steadfast commitment to client success.
Services
ERISA Life Insurance Denial Long Term Disability Claims Short Term Disability Claims Social Security Disability Denial
Details
  • Year established: 1991
Highlights and features
  • We operate on a contingency fee basis with no upfront costs.
  • Our firm has focused on ERISA disability claims since 2004.
  • We collect comprehensive medical evidence to prove disability.
  • Our attorneys have over 30 years of combined legal experience.
  • We serve clients in 10+ states with personalized case strategies.
What people say
Outstanding representation Phenomenal law office Highly recommend Beyond amazing Fantastic
Services
ERISA Life Insurance Denial
We specialize in challenging denied ERISA-governed life insurance claims, addressing misrepresentations, beneficiary disputes, and policy lapses. Our team gathers documentation, secures expert testimonies, and navigates federal regulations to recover rightful benefits. Clients benefit from our contingency fee model and decades of experience in insurance litigation.
Long Term Disability Claims
Our firm handles long-term disability denials by proving clients' inability to perform job duties through medical evidence and vocational analysis. We combat insurers' tactics to minimize payouts, leveraging ERISA expertise and a track record of successful appeals for conditions ranging from chronic illness to catastrophic injuries.
Short Term Disability Claims
We advocate for clients denied short-term disability benefits, ensuring proper documentation submission and challenging insurers' premature denials. Our approach prevents future long-term disability claim complications by establishing a strong evidentiary foundation early in the process.
Social Security Disability Denial
We represent clients denied Social Security Disability benefits, focusing on medical documentation gaps and work limitation proof. Our team navigates the multi-year appeals process, ensuring compliance with strict deadlines and presenting cases tailored to Social Security Administration requirements.
People
Joseph P. McDonald
Attorney | President | Owner
Joseph McDonald, an Ohio bar-certified attorney since 1991, specializes in ERISA disability and life insurance claims. With prior experience as a city attorney and personal injury lawyer, he brings over three decades of legal expertise to complex insurance litigation.
Christine M. McDonald
Attorney | Vice-President | Owner
Christine McDonald, admitted to the Ohio bar in 1993, focuses on disability and life insurance appeals. Her background includes prosecution and legal research, complementing her advocacy for clients denied employer-provided benefits under ERISA.
Questions
What is ERISA and how does it affect my disability claim?
ERISA is a federal law governing employer-provided benefits. It sets strict guidelines for claim denials and appeals, requiring specialized legal knowledge to navigate successfully.
What should I do if my disability insurance claim is denied?
Contact McDonald & McDonald immediately. We'll review your case, gather medical evidence, and build an appeal within ERISA's strict deadlines to maximize your chances of success.
How are attorney fees structured for insurance appeals?
We work on a contingency fee basis—no upfront costs. You pay no attorney fees unless we win your case and recover your benefits.
Can I appeal a Social Security disability denial?
Yes. We handle SSDI appeals, including administrative hearings and federal court litigation, ensuring proper medical documentation and compliance with SSA requirements.
Do you represent clients outside Ohio?
Yes. We handle ERISA cases in Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, New York, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Wisconsin, and Vermont, leveraging federal law expertise regardless of location.
Videos