Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
37 Years
experience
Your Trusted Legal Partner in Jamestown, NY
Since 1989, Bly Sheffield Bargar & Pillittieri has served individuals and families in Jamestown, NY, providing trusted legal representation across diverse practice areas. Our firm combines multidisciplinary expertise with personalized attention to address complex legal challenges, including personal injury, criminal defense, family law, and real estate matters. With decades of collective experience, we prioritize client needs while maintaining a strong commitment to community service and ethical practice.

Our attorneys, including Peter A. Pillittieri, bring specialized knowledge and local insight to every case, ensuring clients receive strategic counsel tailored to their unique circumstances. We remain dedicated to delivering results-driven legal solutions while upholding the highest standards of professionalism and client advocacy.
Services
Auto accidents Personal injury Divorce law Real estate Criminal defense Wills and trusts
Details
  • Year established: 1989
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 30 years of combined legal experience in Chautauqua County
  • Our multidisciplinary approach covers six core practice areas
  • Personalized attention from attorneys deeply rooted in the community
  • Active involvement in local legal associations and civic organizations
  • Proven track record in complex litigation and settlement negotiations
Services
Personal injury
We represent clients in personal injury cases resulting from auto accidents and other incidents. Our attorneys seek compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and emotional distress. With decades of experience, we provide strategic legal guidance through complex litigation and settlement negotiations.
Criminal defense
Our firm defends clients facing misdemeanor and felony charges, including traffic violations and drug offenses. We leverage deep knowledge of the criminal justice system to protect client rights. Our approach combines aggressive representation with personalized legal strategies tailored to each case.
Divorce law
We handle divorce proceedings, child support calculations, and family mediation matters. Our attorneys provide compassionate guidance through emotionally challenging situations. We assist with contested divorces, visitation rights, and other family law issues specific to New York regulations.
Real estate
Our legal services cover real estate transactions and disputes in Chautauqua County. We assist with property transfers, contract negotiations, and title issues. The firm provides comprehensive representation for residential and commercial real estate matters.
Wills and trusts
We help clients create comprehensive estate plans including wills, trusts, and advance directives. Our attorneys ensure proper asset distribution and healthcare directives. We provide guidance on probate matters and estate administration in New York.
People
Peter A. Pillittieri
Attorney
Admitted to the New York Bar in 1993, Peter Pillittieri specializes in criminal law, family law, personal injury, and real estate. He serves on the Jamestown Area Midget Football Mediation Panel and is active in local legal associations.
Questions
What practice areas does Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri handle?
We specialize in personal injury, criminal defense, family law, real estate, and estate planning. Our attorneys provide comprehensive legal representation across six core practice areas.
Does your firm serve areas outside Jamestown?
While based in Jamestown, we serve clients throughout Chautauqua County and surrounding regions with personalized legal representation.
What experience does your firm have in criminal defense?
Our attorneys have over 30 years of combined experience handling misdemeanor and felony cases, including traffic violations, drug offenses, and domestic violence charges.
Can your firm assist with estate planning documents?
Yes, we help create wills, trusts, and advance healthcare directives to ensure proper asset distribution and end-of-life care preferences.