Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Trusted Legal Representation in Rutland, Vermont
At Cleary Shahi & Aicher, we provide assertive legal representation rooted in over 160 years of combined litigation experience. Our team of seasoned attorneys specializes in complex legal matters ranging from personal injury defense to professional malpractice litigation, employment law, and insurance disputes. We prioritize client needs by developing tailored courtroom strategies while maintaining a commitment to clear communication and cost-effective solutions. Our attorneys, recognized by legal directories such as Best Lawyers and Chambers and Partners, bring decades of expertise in both state and federal litigation.

We leverage extensive professional networks to access technical experts, ensuring robust defense strategies for individuals and businesses facing high-stakes legal challenges. With a focus on protecting clients' rights and minimizing liability exposure, we combine zealous advocacy with practical counsel to achieve favorable outcomes.
Services
Personal Injury Defense Employment Law Professional Malpractice Insurance Litigation Commercial Litigation Construction Law Family Law Will and Probate Law
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 160 years of combined litigation experience in Vermont courts
  • Our attorneys hold AV Preeminent Ratings from Martindale-Hubbell
  • We develop customized courtroom strategies for complex legal matters
  • Our team includes specialists in insurance litigation and catastrophic injury cases
  • We maintain transparent communication throughout the legal process
Associations and certifications
  • AV Preeminent Rating
Services
Personal Injury Defense
We defend clients in personal injury claims involving catastrophic injuries, auto accidents, and premises liability. Our attorneys leverage decades of trial experience to minimize liability exposure while protecting clients' interests in both state and federal courts.
Employment Law
Our firm handles employment litigation matters including discrimination claims, wage disputes, and wrongful termination cases. We represent businesses in compliance matters and courtroom proceedings, drawing on specialized knowledge of Vermont labor regulations and federal employment laws.
Professional Malpractice
We defend professionals against malpractice claims in medical, legal, and architectural/engineering disciplines. Our attorneys utilize technical experts and industry-specific knowledge to build strong defense strategies for complex liability cases involving professional standards of care.
Insurance Litigation
Our practice includes representing insurance companies in coverage disputes and bad faith claims. We handle catastrophic injury cases, product liability matters, and complex insurance defense strategies with a focus on cost-effective resolution and courtroom advocacy.
Commercial Litigation
We resolve business conflicts involving contracts, commercial transactions, and corporate liability. Our attorneys provide strategic counsel for multi-party disputes and complex litigation matters, combining trial readiness with negotiation expertise to protect business interests.
People
David L. Cleary
Of Counsel
Founder with trial experience since 1970, recognized by Best Lawyers and Chambers and Partners as Vermont's leading trial attorney, specializing in complex litigation and insurance defense.
Kaveh S. Shahi
Partner
Specializes in insurance law and catastrophic personal injury cases, with extensive experience in appellate litigation and complex insurance coverage matters.
Thomas P. Aicher
Partner
Handles catastrophic product injuries and outdoor recreation liability claims, bringing expertise in high-level personal injury defense and construction defect litigation.
Joel P. Iannuzzi
Partner
Litigation specialist since 1984 with focus on personal injury, employment disputes, and insurance coverage matters, recognized for dedicated advocacy in complex legal cases.
Ellie Gebarowski-Shafer
Associate Attorney
Emerging legal professional supporting diverse practice areas including litigation defense and civil matters, contributing fresh perspective to client case strategies.
Questions
What areas of law does Cleary Shahi & Aicher specialize in?
We specialize in personal injury defense, employment law, professional malpractice, insurance litigation, commercial disputes, and construction law matters.
How much litigation experience does your team have?
Our attorneys collectively bring over 160 years of combined litigation experience in Vermont and federal courts across diverse practice areas.
Do you offer free initial consultations?
Yes, we provide complimentary initial consultations to discuss your legal needs and develop an appropriate case strategy.
How do you handle complex legal cases?
We employ customized courtroom strategies, leverage technical experts, and utilize our extensive litigation experience to manage complex multi-party and catastrophic injury cases.
What makes your firm different from other Vermont law firms?
Our AV Preeminent-rated attorneys combine decades of trial experience with specialized knowledge in niche areas like outdoor recreation liability and insurance coverage disputes.